• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Samuel Mancino's Italian Eatery

Samuel Mancino's Italian Eatery, located in Granger, Indiana, is a beloved gem celebrated for its generous portions and flavorful offerings. Known for their enormous salads, mouthwatering pizzas, and delicious grinders, this eatery has something for everyone. Patrons rave about the chicken bacon salad and the Italian grinder, highlighting their freshness and quality. The welcoming atmosphere enhances the dining experience, making visitors feel right at home. With a commitment to friendly service and a vibrant dining environment, Samuel Mancino’s stands out as a top choice for Italian cuisine enthusiasts. Your next favorite meal awaits here!

Samuel Mancino's Italian Eatery: Reviews & Ratings

Tonya K.
Tonya K.

The salads are AWESOME. They are huge with lots of toppings and reasonably priced. The best salads in this area, imo. The pizza, grinders, and calzones are all excellent. You can't go wrong with anything on their menu.

Jessica Limon
Jessica Limon

I haven’t eaten at a Mancinos in the last 10 years and today I had it. It was just a delicious as I remembered ! Loved the atmosphere at this location too. Food was amazing! I will be back very soon :)

Jess Bee
Jess Bee

For Macinos getting more rare, this one is the BEST in the area. Black and bleu ginder is 5* . Plus we love playing air hockey and basketball while we wait

Jennifer Barstead (Jenni)
Jennifer Barstead (Jenni)

The waitress who took our order was WONDERFUL! DEFINITELY will eat here next time I'm in Granger.

Michael Fantetti
Michael Fantetti

Their chicken bacon salad is one of my favorite meals, and the Italian grinder is phenomenal.

Vicky Creasy
Vicky Creasy

One of our favorite spots in Granger. You must have the Sammy’s bread. Their toasted sandwiches are so yummy! I had ham and cheese this time, but I love the pork, and the roast beef of great! My kiddos love their calzones.

Gary Hall
Gary Hall

I've frequented this location since their original opening, however it's been several months since I had lunch there. I was pleasantly surprised to see they have upgraded the interior furniture to a very inviting atmosphere. The food continues to be a good value and of quality ingredients. The staff was very cheerful and I plan on visiting more frequently in the future.

Cookie C
Cookie C

My husband and I and my mom went here for first time Saturday night and. I ordered The Club sandwich and it was delicious and perfectly toasted My husband ordered his Cordon Blue a little confusing but they got it right. My mom got Ham & Turkey, and for the price sandwiches are a nice portion. Staff was very polite and food was out fast. We will be coming back.

Location

Welcome to Samuel Mancino's Italian Eatery, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Granger, Indiana. Located at 13020 IN-23, this delightful eatery brings a taste of Italy that's hard to resist. With its warm atmosphere and inviting decor, Samuel Mancino's is more than just a dining spot; it’s a place where friends and family gather to indulge in fabulous food and create lasting memories.

As a food reviewer, I couldn't help but be impressed by the array of offerings at this establishment. Renowned for its oversized salads, Samuel Mancino's excels in serving dishes that are as generous as they are delicious. One diner raved about their salads being "AWESOME," packed with toppings and reasonably priced, claiming them to be the best in the area. It's no wonder that both the pizza and calzones have received high praise as well, making it impossible to go wrong with anything on the menu.

The grinders are a standout feature, particularly the highly recommended Black and Bleu Grinder, which has earned five-star reviews. The balance of flavors is exquisite and offers a delightful culinary adventure. Another diner praised the chicken bacon salad and described the Italian grinder as phenomenal. You can sense a consistent passion for food that shines through each dish.

Moreover, the atmosphere at Samuel Mancino's enhances the overall experience. Guests enjoy not only the tantalizing dishes but also engaging activities like air hockey and basketball while waiting for their meals, transforming the dining moment into a fun outing. Customer reviews emphasize that the staff is exceptional, with one diner highlighting the wonderful waitress who took their order, promising to return for another visit.

This Italian eatery reflects the warmth of Italian hospitality, coupled with a menu that captures a wide range of flavors. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Samuel Mancino's Italian Eatery is a destination not to be missed. Get ready to savor the taste of Italy and enjoy a culinary experience that will leave you wanting more!

For inquiries or to place an order, call them at +1 574-243-9000.